Evaluating the two quarterbacks’ performances this period would not give a comprehensive photograph of what the promotions signify to Buffalo. The concern is not whether the Charges upgraded from Taylor to McCarron in 2018. The far more acceptable comparison is no matter if Taylor would have been a better extensive-expression alternative for the Expenditures than whomever the franchise drafts in April and no matter if Buffalo would have been far better off preserving the No. 10 decide on in the 2017 draft and picking Deshaun Watson or Patrick Mahomes.
McCarron is simply the Bills’ bridge quarterback, keeping the seat heat right until the before long-to-be-drafted quarterback is prepared. His signing should do tiny to change Buffalo’s evident plans to explore chances to trade up increased in the 1st round right after attaining the Cincinnati Bengals‘ No. 12 overall choice in a trade this week.
The Bills trading Taylor for the No. 65 all round choose, the initial choice of the third spherical, also gave standard manager Brandon Beane a bigger assortment of belongings to move up the board. How large he can get in the purchase and which quarterback he covets remains to be viewed, but with Taylor absent and no recognized veteran quarterback introduced aboard to substitute him, there is an escalating likelihood the Expenditures acquire a dwelling-operate swing at a quarterback in the draft.
If the Expenditures intend for that draft choice to ease into his NFL career, McCarron could be a feasible starting off quarterback in the brief expression. In the most effective scenario circumstance for Buffalo, he performs properly plenty of to have trade price subsequent offseason, when the reins could be turned about to the youthful quarterback.
There is chance to McCarron. He has started only a few occupation video games, all in 2015. His functionality was promising — he finished 66 p.c of his passes for a 97.1 passer ranking, 6 touchdowns and two interceptions — but the sample sizing was modest. He is significantly from a demonstrated NFL starting up quarterback, and he lacks the graybeard working experience the Bills could have obtained if they had signed a extra founded veteran with fewer upside, these types of as Josh McCown, Derek Anderson or Matt Moore.
If the Charges desired a steadier hand at quarterback with predictable final results, they could have held Taylor at about $18 million. His existence would not have prevented the Charges from choosing a quarterback substantial in April’s draft, and he could have acted as the bridge till that quarterback was prepared, leaving in free of charge company upcoming offseason.
In its place, the Expenditures traded Taylor and in all probability signed McCarron for a lot less, even thinking of Taylor’s $7.6 million lifeless-funds cost. They also picked up a third-spherical select in the approach that could be a valuable chip in finding their fingers on their quarterback of the foreseeable future.
There is credence to the notion Taylor would be the much better quarterback for the Bills in 2018 than McCarron, but to look at people two gamers in a vacuum would not absolutely capture the condition.
Beane and coach Sean McDermott will not be judged on regardless of whether McCarron was a improved quarterback than Taylor, but no matter if whichever quarterback they draft becomes superior than Taylor.